I am the same age my mother was when she gave birth to me. I never considered the age particularly significant, but I have spent much time considering similarities and differences between us. I don’t compare terms like successes and failures, but in terms of which traits we share and where we differ. I’m not competitive by nature, and prefer to improving my shortcomings rather than compete against other’s accomplishments. Spoken like a failure? Maybe, but success isn’t black and white like corporate America would lead one to believe. Sometimes the best you do is simply to better your previous attempt. It isn’t a recipe for curing cancer, but it implies the desire to continue growing.
I shudder when I consider my mother was parenting three children when she was my age. When I see people younger than me, with a one child, I question whether or not they could really be ready for all the responsibility and selflessness it entails. It’s hard to imagine being altruistic and postponing the things I feel driven to do with my life. I always worried that a child would need more of me than I am prepared to give. Habitually, I always hold a little something back from relationships. Even the relationship with the Mister. Restraint is necessary in parenting, but so is being real, and being emotionally available.
Both parents were influential in shaping who I became. As I grow older and more contemplative, I am aware my father had a definite advantage in passing first. As a ghost of my memory, I am less likely to compare myself to him. There is a reverence achieved when life suspends. People are often hesitant to speak of your shortcomings in your absence of defending yourself. Although, in southern cultures they feel free to say whatever they damn well please provided it is prefaced with well bless his/her heart.
My mother and I are alike in many ways, some for better others worse. We are stubborn, self-sufficient, hard working, and determined. We are also easily frustrated by setbacks, non-confrontational, too quick to jump to conclusions and not easily forgiving. I hope I am more flexible than she is today. Aging suppresses flexibility. Maybe she was more flexible at my age, but she was firmly planted by the time I became a teenager.
I wonder where she thought she would be in her life at the age I am. Did she aspire to be more than a wife and mother, or was that enough? She once told me she had considered joining the army after nursing school, but she became smitten with my father and accepted his proposal instead. I also wonder if the army was really HER dream, or one my aunt had thrust upon her. My family has a long history of woman assigning their dreams to their progeny. My grandmother, my mother, my aunt, all guilty. I suppose that’s another tradition I would have chosen to abandon had I become a parent. Everyone should choose their own dreams, without the burden of vicariousness thrust upon their shoulders.
I hope her stubbornness will be beneficial in the right ways. That it will give me the strength to persevere and find my way in the world. The notion of independence is ironic. On one level, I think it pleased my mother to raise three independent children, but on the other hand, I think she wished I needed her more and was more malleable to her influence. Like her, I have my own ideas and do not change my mind without considerable thought. Unlike her, I don’t give a shit if you believe in the things I believe in, and I have no desire to change your beliefs so they imitate mine.
Approval is unimportant to me. I consider whether or not my actions are knowingly inconsiderate to others. I place value on common courtesy. My rights shouldn’t infringe upon your rights, but if my actions offend your sensibilities, you’ll have to deal with it on your own. I have difficulty living up to my expectations, don’t be disappointed if I don’t consider your expectations of me.
People grow and change, and yet adult children still access their parent’s strengths and weaknesses from the point of view as teenagers, and aging parents still treat their adult children like eleven year olds who don’t have enough common sense to come in out of the rain. My mother mentions how proud she is of her adult children, but she seldom praised our accomplishments during the ages it mattered most. She always clung to the notion we holding on out, or that we should doing better. All our accomplishments weren’t worthy of praise, but undermining our self-confidence was a hardly an effective motivator.
Unfortunately my thirteen year-old memory is more vivid than my thirty-plus year old memory. My default reaction is to associate her with the disapproving matriarch of my youth, just as her default memory of me is the irresponsible thirteen year old who was too uncoordinated to master a steak knife. I suppose that makes us even.
July 11th, 2008 at 1:51 pm
I feel deeply your point about parenting being a selfless job. I’m not that good at it. My inheritance passed from Grandmother to mother to me has hindered my progress but I persevere. And my children show the effects of it. But I wonder how the comparisons of myself will hold up when they get to that age.
I’ve always hated the fact that my mother still sees me as a child, but it’s even in a way I suppose that I still see her as a mother good and bad. I love that you can peer so deeply into these relationships and come out with gorgeous nuggets that prompt so much thinking.
July 11th, 2008 at 4:21 pm
I’ve made similar comparisons between my age and my mother’s.
My sister had already dropped out of college. I was eight, two teenaged brothers in the middle. She was just going back to work full-time.
I think that restraint would serve a person really well as a parent. If anything, I’m too transparent.
I wouldn’t say that my mother is unable to see me as an adult as much as I think she see doesn’t see ME at all. She just takes it for granted that her opinion or desire is the only reasonable one, and proceeds to swamp any small craft in her wake.
July 11th, 2008 at 9:35 pm
this is settling into my heart as we speak.
July 11th, 2008 at 11:18 pm
Much of this sounds familiar to me.
It’s good that your mother has grown so that she can praise her adult children. Is your mother as contemplative as you are?
You have well descibed the danger of raising independant kids. Does she treat your other siblings as their awkward 13 year old selves? Or is it just because you are the one who hasn’t reproduced.
July 12th, 2008 at 10:03 am
Maggie, I think you’re being harsh about your own abilities. Even those who reach “good parenting status” reach it through trial and error. I don’t know a single parent who doesn’t wish they hadn’t tackled certain situations differently. It is interesting to look at the parenting history and see what techniques evolved from Grandma, and which ones were abandon.
De, you and I grew up in similar situations. The youngest of multiple siblings, parent returning to work. It sounds like your mother is used to calling the shots. My mother would like to have that kind of power, she really tries to exert it, but her input is often ignored.
flutter, everyone has different comparisons to make.
meno, I don’t think she is as contemplative, meditative maybe, but not exactly the same thing.
She is more likely to treat my siblings as grown ups. I think she treats me as a kid because she didn’t witness my maturing as much as the other two. She returned to work full-time when I was 7 or 8. I’m not criticizing her return to work versus staying at home. I’m glad she returned to work for her and for me. It gave me more room to grow independent. I also believe sexism factors into this as she cuts my brother more slack than my sister or myself….just like her own mother.
July 13th, 2008 at 5:58 pm
I like how you know yourself so well and are unapologetic.
It is rare to be able to have that kind of surety.
July 14th, 2008 at 7:40 am
I’m at the same point - my mum had me at 27, and I just reel at how different our life charts are…
Cxx
July 14th, 2008 at 10:17 pm
crazymumma,it’s demeaning to yourself and others to issue apologies you don’t mean.
Claire, when we’re young we have all these expectations of how our lives will turn out, but we never what our future holds.
July 14th, 2008 at 11:08 pm
I have difficulty navigating my relationship with my parents for other reasons, but one thing you said did stick out to me. My mother always wanted to me to grow up and not ever depend on anyone. I don’t think she realized she would eventually be included in the definition.
July 14th, 2008 at 11:19 pm
Very deep thoughts, and naturally propell me to think my own deep thoughts. your posts have a tendency to do that to me.
I don’t know what my mother thinks of me…from the moment she found out I was deaf, I think all her fantasies and expectations and hope for her baby girl had to change: she had to abandon all her expections in order to give me the training and attention I needed to learn to function in a hearing world.
Now that I am pushing 30, I don’t think she views me as a child, exactly, any more. She still mothers me, but out of habit I think, to remind me of how to take care of myself, since we live so far apart now…
I miss my mom.
July 15th, 2008 at 8:18 pm
qt, the only thing worse than not getting what we want, is getting exactly what we want.
rachel, the most selfless adjust their dreams for the benefit of the whole. It can be necessary to make minor adjustments to dreams, and it’s possible your mother’s dreams for you never changed, just the manner in which she approached them.