As an adult, holidays have evolved into seasonal events I tolerate on behalf of others, my obligatory concession to family. Long jaded by consumerism, I try putting up a brave front so my family and the Mister’s, can have “their” celebration the way they desire it. Ironically, after all the hoop jumping, they are seldom happy with the results.
What I have difficulty justifying, are all the stress-inducing obligations executed under the guise of celebration. Many, I’m obligated to celebrate with, have a talent for placing more emphasis on the ritual than the meaning. Why exalt stress and place it on a pedestal with a ten page credit card statement and a bottle of xanax? Because we’ve always done it that way. We obsess over cumbersome traditions, and abandon the most rewarding aspect of celebration, appreciation.
On the surface, I might seem ungrateful. I’m not. I appreciate everyone who has ever hosted a gathering and included me at their table. What I don’t enjoy are loud crowds, poor planning, having to carry on when the self-appointed hostess losses her shit, watching the Host’s husband drink pot liquor from the serving dish with the serving spoon, my father-in-law snatching turkey off my plate and drinking from my glass, the hosting couple exchanging loud insults at the dinner table, one person being burdened with all the preparations because they won’t allow others to help, and spending four hours commuting between two locations with equally unpleasant circumstances, and tiptoeing around pre-approved topics of conversation (weather, football, fishing, boy scouts).
Prior to this year, the most enjoyable Thanksgiving I had celebrated as an adult doesn’t qualify as much of a Thanksgiving at all. Mister Hombre had to work, and invited me to travel with him. We walked along Fisherman’s Wharf in San Francisco and watched the sea lions sunbathe. We ate non-traditional fare and explored the hills and squares of one of my favorite cities. That trip raised the bar for holidays. After that, I hoped he would have to work Thanksgiving regularly (my unpleasant selfishness makes itself known).
The following year, he was home, and we took his parents out for Thanksgiving. It went as expected. Lots of complaints about the food (Justified, I’m afraid. The turkey was truly awful.) Complaints about the lack of family present, complaints about health, complaints, complaints, complaints…
I didn’t discuss Thanksgiving with the Mister this year. I hoped he would be working, but it didn’t seem right to ask. I thought he still enjoyed the holidays. We didn’t discuss Thanksgiving until two weeks ago. I knew I could handle the truth, but I didn’t want to marinate in it. I didn’t want to determine the outcome before the event arrived, as I am prone. The Mister gave me his schedule, and he would be working six days across Thanksgiving. I felt guilty and excited. Guilty he would be away from his family and it was what I wanted, and excited because I could travel with him.
Last week, I asked if he tried to get Thanksgiving off. His responded that he ignored the holiday when he was bidding for his schedule. I feel bad for him, because until now, he has enjoyed the holidays, warts and all. I think the pressure of being everything to everyone is weighing him down. Parents, kids. job, and wife pulling in different directions. Especially parents. I long for him to enjoy the holidays, the way he did when our relationship was new, even if I don’t feel the same, it isn’t always about me. Some of us learn sooner than others, you never really can go home again.
This year, we spent Thanksgiving in Munich, with a table full of other Americans away from their families. We ate traditional German food, and there was no shortage of laughter. Thankful me. There are things I still enjoy about the holidays, like watching kids consumed by excitement, hearing my grandmother say, “shit”, spending casual time with friends, and saying thank you, for being you. But, seriously why should I wait for the holidays to enjoy those things, I should appreciate what I have daily, wherever I happen to be.
November 24th, 2007 at 12:18 am
Yours sounds like a sane response to what has become insane - the ‘celebration’ of holidays. Glad you had a happy one.
November 24th, 2007 at 1:00 am
Thank you.
November 24th, 2007 at 1:42 am
There does seem to be a strong corruption of the holiday spirit doesn’t there? Thanksgiving has never been a pressure for me - I live too far away from family to ever go there so it always ends up being potluck with goups of friends with games of scrabble afterwards. Frohe Andedanksfest!
November 24th, 2007 at 3:02 am
Amen.
November 24th, 2007 at 10:51 am
It’s funny, I spent a Thanksgiving in the tropics once, dining on rock lobster and drinking rum and it was hands down the most carefree Thanksgiving ever!
I normally love the holidays because I love to cook. And I love MY family gatherings. The BF’s family - not so much, but at least everyone is civil.
Your Thanksgiving sounds like it was a lot of fun, and laughter should be celebrated whenever it is present, I concur.
November 24th, 2007 at 11:45 am
It really is unfortunate that we have to grow up and can no longer remain oblivious to the drama (and psychodrama) that often accompanies not only holiday celebrations, but family get togethers. Sometimes you have to break from tradition, in order to start a new one.
November 24th, 2007 at 4:50 pm
I agree. When are you going to reconnoiter with me in the ATL?? Remember my condo? Yeah, you heard right, sister. C-A-L-L me!
November 25th, 2007 at 5:34 pm
My god! That sounds like the best. I was telling the Mister as we were driving home from Thanksgiving this year, that next year we should arrange to be out of town.
November 27th, 2007 at 2:58 am
My sister in law talks about how Vegas last year was her best year ever. Of course, that meant not being with me and the family, so I should be insulted. But for all the reasons you’ve outlined, I couldn’t be. I find you quite sane and appropriate (and this coming from someone who LOVES holidays and family gatherings.)
November 27th, 2007 at 1:37 pm
Talk to me in a year. I said I’d host Thanksgiving from now on. No matter what, the good part about this is that I won’t have to be two places in one day.
November 27th, 2007 at 5:05 pm
nancy, and a good time was had be all… When I was single, it was never acceptable for me to turn turn down invitations to these circus gatherings. I’ve become rather spoiled having my husband’s job available as an excuse. Of course he’s become spoiled by it too.
crazymumma, and also to you ;).
Wayfarer, I’m partial to the relaxed potluck gatherings. It’s nice to spend time with family, but when you’re always together for the holidays, it’s easier to slip into the nasty habit of taking one another for granted.
Flutter, do I detect the tone of been there, done that?
qt, it’s great that you have a long history of good celebrations to boast. Years ago, I could say the same. Now, everyone is so demanding and disgruntled about it. Bleh! It’s only fair they celebrate together.
Good beer=Good Thanksgiving=Good bowling.
Lynn, we might have a new tradition. The Mister commented on how pleasant and carefree the occasion was. Now for Christmas…
princess liv of everything, luv the new title! I will call soon. I almost called last night on my way home form the airport, but I seem to have come in contact with some kind of mysterious scratchy throat, fever spiking, not fit to be in the presence of human’s with little ones kind of ailment. How was the beach?
meno, I’ll help you find a suitable retreat ;).
mama p, the holidays give me performance anxiety. There is an unspoken expectation, that I not run with scissors and play well with others, even when none of the other reasonable people can’t stand to be around them either. I always like to hear about people who enjoy the holidays. It’s good to know their are plenty of folks around who know how to celebrate right!
De, I will follow-up. I hate the two places at once. I’ve tried different strategies, all failed, except this year’s…
November 27th, 2007 at 6:19 pm
I love this post. Being in Canada and none of my husband’s family do much for Thanksgiving has afforded us the opportunity to have small celebrations with just our little family and we really love it. But Christmas is just like what you describe with parties that are way over-crowded with my husband’s cousins and uncles and aunts - who among them several have decided that we are apparently ‘poor relations’ and therefore they feel the need to sneak off with the good wines to drink without us - such a weird story. Anyways, what with the kids and the fact that we have to pack practically the whole house to go to these things and then travel for two hours only to feel bad, we made the tough decision that we are not attending the big family party any more - not necessarily a great thing from his parent’s point of view. But it was such a chore and so depressing AND they always held it on Christmas day which is so difficult to have our own family traditions and then rush off. Anyhow, I do go on. This was a lovely post.
November 30th, 2007 at 12:17 am
Maggie, I’m something of a sourpuss when it comes to holiday traditions. I don’t want to abandon all the old traditions, but I think it is important to start new ones. When they become chores, it’s time to move forward and leave them behind.
I know it wasn’t an easy decision for you and your husband. Hopefully this year you will began new traditions and recapture the enjoyment of the holiday season for the whole family.
December 7th, 2007 at 8:45 am
I feel fortunate that even though I’m almost 40 years old, my parents still insist on hosting Thanksgiving (which falls near my parents’ anniversary). Because they are Greek and own their kitchen, I get kicked out when I try to help.
Is the madness similar for you during the Christmas holiday as well?
December 9th, 2007 at 10:44 pm
Diane Mandy, I like the idea of getting kicked out of the kitchen, but it is frequently short lived and often followed by, a chorus of, “You’re doing it wrong.”
Yes, Christmas is the same way. I am learning to laugh about it and accept that the holidays are for the benefit of others, and my favorite cafe is for the benefit of me to recoup after the seasonal bliss.