Mother daughter relationships are incomprehensible under the best of circumstances. They are intricate, delicate and fragile like a spider web. There are no hard and fast rules about whether mothers will have a stronger relationship with their sons or daughters. I’ve watched the pendulum swing both ways. WIth the division of genes, there is a chance a child of either sex will have enough of your traits to make a significant relationship impossible.
As a teenager, I thought I came from a dysfunctional family. Dysfunctional families have been around since the dawn parental partnerships, but the phrase “dysfunctional” began to pick up steam during the late eighties. I wore “dysfunctional” with all the pride of a discharged sailor sporting an anchor tattoo on his triceps.
Before I started high school, my mom entered treatment for alcohol and prescription drug abuse. Getting treatment, was still a tabu in southeast. All those lectures my father launched into about saving face and not embarrassing the family, and look who embarrassed the family. By then, my siblings were in college or holding down jobs and I was the last fledgling in the nest.
Mom completed her treatment and came home to a teenager who didn’t respect her anymore. Her six week absence, put her in the position re-earning my trust and re-establishing herself as an authority figure. A daunting task at best, but further complicated by my hormone haze and a forced school change.
While that event changed the balance of power, it never really changed the nature of our relationship. I had an unexplainable distrust of her before she sought treatment and it was tightly maintained once she returned home. She atoned for her mistake, and I’m proud of her for maintaining her sobriety but I doubt that I will ever feel close to her.
Post voting age, I realized my family didn’t embody the designer dysfunctional label. My parents addressed the problems that classified us as broken, thus repairing the cracks in our foundation. It’s interesting that I misinterpreted problem solving as a public humiliation. If had continued such thoughts, I would become the sweet heart of denial. Further proof hormonal haze and excessive masturbating affects you ability to see things clearly.
Today, I have a respectful, though distant relationship with my mother. I admire her strength and character. I recognize we share many of the same characteristics. She IS the crazy old cat woman, and I am destined to become one. I try to be there for her and pitch in when she needs a hand and can’t admit it. I abhor her stubbornness, because it closely resembles my own.
I used to regret we do not share one of THOSE relationships. I am largely to blame because I never felt warm, comforting safety in her arms. I never wanted to confide in her, lest she would pass judgement. There are plenty of times I endure her affection and restrain myself from pulling away. I can’t explain the why only that it just is. I am not interested in forcing our relationship to be one of THOSE relationships, because I don’t believe in forcing relationships. Forcing is not synonymous with nurturing. So like a pair of positively charged magnets we repel each other, because we are too much alike.
Today there is no regret, only acceptance. I accept that we need different things, different influences, and different comforts. As long as her needs are met, I will not waste time worrying if they are met by me or one of my siblings.
June 18th, 2007 at 9:26 pm
that last paragraph sounds like me—maybe I am less tapped in to the acceptance bit, but you do have a couple of years on me according to Patches.
I can’t worry about the collective’s happiness any longer. The collective hasn’t worried too much about me. It’s sort of done.
June 19th, 2007 at 6:36 am
“It’s interesting that I misinterpreted problem solving as a public humiliation.” It is interesting, but not all that uncommon. Or at least, it’s familiar to me.
I never wanted to confide in her, lest she would pass judgement. My mother’s judgement is what pushes us apart. She feels it is her God-given right. I think she should stuff it and let me live my own life, and she’s forcing me to withhold myself from her because she won’t (or can’t) stop.
Thought-provoking.
June 19th, 2007 at 12:01 pm
My mother passed judgement on me all the time when i was in her power, for things that were normal, healthy kid things. It is not a surprise to me that i keep myself close and tight when i am around her now. So i get it with you and your mother.
I wonder what the coming years will mean to Em and i too.
June 19th, 2007 at 3:08 pm
liv, it took me a long time to come to terms with it. I felt driven by necessity. I will be addressing the same issues with my mother in a few years, that my spouse is addressing now with his parents. My mother is on the fast track to aging due to disability. I want to be in the proper mindset to get her the care she needs, and that means I need to leave my personal baggage behind when the time comes. Makes me so hate being a grownup.
De, the interesting thing about the public humiliation part is the public tends to forget it more quickly than I do. Thus the world rotates around the life of a teenager instead of the sun.
You bring up an excellent point about the God-given right to judge. When I consider the relationship between my grandmother and my mother, I can clearly see my mother got the inclination honestly. My grandmother is on of the most judgmental persons in my family. I love her, absolutely adore her, but I am so grateful I didn’t grow up under her direction. My mother is judgement light in comparison.
meno, you’ve learned from personal experience how NOT to go about building a relationship. No doubt the years will bring changes in your relationship with Em. They always do. She may lose her way for a little while, but everything you’ve taught her up until that moment will remain with her. I am confident she will always find her way back to you.
June 20th, 2007 at 2:41 pm
I have to tell you how much I respect your reply because I just haven’t been able to come to a place where I feel at peace about having the responsibility of taking care of Mother. I feel like she’s been on the road to killing herself for so long. It’s been hard to watch, and I just somehow feel like she shouldn’t get my help. I don’t want to give it because she never gave it. I don’t know how to cast aside that personal business.
June 20th, 2007 at 5:48 pm
It takes a long time (if at all) to get to the point where you just accept what is instead of saying “Why aren’t we like other people?” all the time (and I am speaking from personal experience here).
I can relate to many of your points made.
June 20th, 2007 at 5:56 pm
I think I need my glasses when I read your blog! Either that, or I need to get them checked.
My eyes must be getting old (not me, of course!). Yikes.
June 20th, 2007 at 11:56 pm
liv, everyone has an extended history that is impossible to sum up in a few paragraphs. I’m fortunate, because my mother the made to effort to right our relationship, and I recognize and appreciate it. We’re just incompatible.
My feelings are not so noble toward my in-laws. I’m not proud of that, but for me to deny it doesn’t change anything; it’s just dishonest.
I too, find it difficult to extend help to people who do not try to help themselves. I know how difficult it can be resolving forgiveness, affirmation, closure, and guilt. One gift to give yourself is to work toward closure while you have the opportunity. Closure for you, to make liv stronger, is not entirely dependent upon Mom’s cooperation. If you must, you can achieve it on your own.
June 22nd, 2007 at 9:56 am
sari, when you are trying to find and accept the person you are it seems like a lonely journey. Maybe it’s because it is about coming to terms for self. It’s taken me a while to notice the path is well worn from all those who made the trip before me.
The type is a little small. I think if you press Control+ (plus sign) or Command + (plus sign) your browser will increase the font size.